Skip to main content
Back to blog
ArticleBy Team Valor AIPublished November 6, 2026

Was Your Old VA Appeal Wrongly Closed? The Freund v. Collins Settlement, Explained

Read the full note here, then bring the context into chat if you want help applying it to your own claim-prep workflow.

Ask Valor
Listen to this article

Audio playback is available only to paid users of the platform.

Checking audio access…

For 35 years, a tracking database inside the VA decided whether an appeal was on time. If the system showed no timely Substantive Appeal on file, the appeal was closed as late. A class action, Freund v. Collins, says that is not what happened in thousands of cases: the appeals were filed on time and closed anyway. The court approved a settlement on August 19, 2026 under which VA will audit the closed files and reopen the ones that should never have been shut. Here is who it covers, where it stands, and what to do if a letter about it arrives.

Quick summary: Under the VA's old legacy appeals system, a database called VACOLS closed an appeal when it showed no timely Substantive Appeal on file. The settlement in Freund v. Collins covers appeal files closed between December 12, 1990 and February 6, 2025. VA will manually audit 28,258 flagged files and send individualized notices for up to 64,599 more. The court approved the settlement on August 19, 2026, after a fairness hearing on August 13, 2026. There is no automatic payout. A reopened appeal still has to be granted before any benefits are paid.

What happened: the VACOLS problem

Before the Appeals Modernization Act took effect in February 2019, veterans appealed under the legacy system. After a denial, a veteran who wanted to keep appealing filed a Substantive Appeal, usually on VA Form 9, to send the case to the Board of Veterans Appeals. VA tracked those appeals in a database called the Veterans Appeals Control and Locator System, or VACOLS.

According to the lawsuit, VACOLS closed appeals as late when its records showed no timely Substantive Appeal, even where the veteran had filed one on time. The paperwork existed; the system said it did not.

The case is Freund v. Collins, No. 21-4168, in the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims. The court certified it as a class action on March 18, 2026, after the parties filed a proposed settlement on December 16, 2025. VA published a public notice of the proposal on April 15, 2026.

Who it covers

The class is narrow, and the dates matter. It covers claimants whose appeal file in VACOLS was closed between December 12, 1990 and February 6, 2025 because VA records showed no timely Substantive Appeal, and whose appeal remains closed. In practice:

  • Your original VA decision was generally before February 19, 2019, when the legacy system gave way to the Appeals Modernization Act.
  • Your appeal was closed as late, not decided. If the Board decided your appeal, this settlement is not about your case.
  • The closure falls inside the window. December 12, 1990 through February 6, 2025.

Under the approved settlement, VA will manually review the 28,258 closed files most likely to contain a timely Substantive Appeal, and reactivate any appeal shut down in error. For up to 64,599 more files, VA will send individualized notices so those veterans or their survivors can ask for a review. Together, that is more than 90,000 veterans and families who could be affected.

Where it stands now

The settlement is approved. On August 19, 2026, the court approved the settlement agreement and granted the parties' joint motion to terminate the case, finding the terms fair, reasonable, and adequate.

  • The court certified the class on March 18, 2026, VA notified class members, and the window to object closed on May 15, 2026.
  • The court held a fairness hearing on August 13, 2026 and overruled the single true objection to the settlement.
  • The terms bind VA and all class members; there is no opt-out.

With approval in place, the audit and notice process in the settlement can proceed. No veteran needs to file anything to be part of the class, and no one should pay anyone who offers to get them into it.

What it does not do

The settlement does not send checks, and it does not grant claims. A reopened appeal still has to go through the VA process, with updated medical evidence and ratings, and be granted before any benefits are paid. If it is granted, the effective date could go back to the original claim, which is where back pay comes from. That is a possibility, not a promise, and anyone who tells you a dollar amount your reopened appeal is worth is guessing.

It also does not fix every old appeal. A denial you never appealed, an appeal the Board decided, or a claim decided under the modern system is a different situation. Our guide to Supplemental Claim vs Higher-Level Review explains the review lanes for decisions still open to challenge.

What to do now: a checklist

There is no form to file today, but there are things worth doing while VA carries out the approved review process.

  • 1. Keep any VA letter that names Freund v. Collins. If a letter arrives naming the case or case number 21-4168, keep it, keep the envelope it came in, and read what it asks for. Do not throw it away because it looks like a routine notice.
  • 2. Check your dates against the class: original decision generally before February 19, 2019, appeal closed between December 12, 1990 and February 6, 2025, and still closed. If your dates do not fit, this settlement is probably not your path.
  • 3. Gather your old appeal paperwork: the decision letter, your Substantive Appeal or proof you filed it, and any letter saying the appeal was closed. A free accredited VSO can help you request your file if you no longer have copies.
  • 4. Talk to a free accredited VSO before filing anything new on the same issue, because a new filing can change how an old appeal is handled.
  • 5. If you are a surviving spouse or family member, the same notice may apply to you, because the class includes survivors. Keep the letter and ask a VSO what it means for your claim.
  • 6. Make sure VA has your current mailing address, since notices go by mail. If you have moved since your appeal was closed, update your address with VA.
  • 7. Do nothing else until a notice arrives. VA's own notice says that if you do nothing, your case may still receive the review or notice described above now that the court has approved the settlement. There is no deadline to beat right now.

How ValorAI can help

If a letter about Freund arrives, the first job is understanding what it says. ValorAI can help you organize your decision letter and old appeal paperwork, check what your file is missing, and prepare questions to take to a free accredited VSO. Our guide to auditing your decision letter shows how to read one line by line.

ValorAI is prep support only. It is not VA, a VSO, or an accredited representative, it does not file claims or appeals for you, and it does not speed up VA decisions.

Official sources

This article is for informational purposes and is not legal advice.

Continue here

Use the product directly after reading the article.

Upload a document